The Garden City Historical Society
Garden City, Long Island, New York
About Us
Events & Lectures

View Historic Structure Listings

Join our Historic Structure Survey

A. T. Stewart Exchange
Consignment Shop
Hours: Tuesday through Friday:
10 a.m. - 4 p.m.
Saturday: noon - 4 p.m.
(516) 746-8900
(Entrance and parking at the rear of the Museum
109 Eleventh Street,
Garden City, New York)

Museum Visiting Hours: Thursdays, 11 am to 2 pm
Please come visit us. Walk-ins encouraged to see this 1872 historic house and Museum.
PLEASE NOTE: Visiting hours are temporarily suspended until March 14. 

Proud member of
Museum Association of New York

American Association for State and Local History

Historical Society Plans Benefit for September 20

The Garden City Historical Society will pay tribute to Garden City's 150 Anniversary at its annual Fundraising Benefit, scheduled for Friday, September 20, 7-11 p.m. at the Garden City Hotel. Proceeds go to the Society's Capital Campaign Restoration Project.

This year, the Society honors "Local Heroes" whose organizations work on behalf of children. The honorees are: The Andy Foundation - Jill Palmeri, The Mollie Foundation - Maggie and Jack Biggane, and the GCAA Challenger Sports Program - Al Vanasco.

Tickets are now on sale at the Society's A. T. Stewart Exchange consignment shop, entrance at the rear of the museum, Tuesdays-Fridays from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. and Saturdays from noon to 4 p.m. Information can also be found at

Historical Society Receives Grant from the Robert David Lion Gardiner Foundation

In July, The Garden City Historical Society was awarded a "Capacity Building" grant from the Robert David Lion Gardiner Foundation. Through this generous grant, the Society will be able to enhance its administrative functions and increase its technology equipment. Find out more about the Gardiner Foundation award.

Gardiner Foundation Executive Director Kathryn Curran, second from left, congratulates members of The Garden City Historical Society Board of Trustees, from left, Francine Ryan, President Mary Mahoney, Kate Schmidt and Bill Garry, on the Society's grant award.

Society's Archives Committee Leads Tours

embers of the Society's Archives and Acquisition Committee led two tours of the historic central section of Garden City for members of the Garden City High School Class of 1968, who were celebrating their 50th Class Reunion. The bus tours circled around such sites as St. Paul's School, the Cathedral of the Incarnation and the Diocese See House, the Garden City Casino, the LIRR station, the War Memorials, the Garden City Hotel, the buildings on Hilton Avenue that served as Garden City's first stores, the Toll House that now serves as home for  the Garden City Chamber of Commerce, and the headquarters of The Garden City Historical Society Museum. Look for future tour opportunities.

Music Series Welcomes Andrew Andron Quartet

Local resident Andrew Andron's Quartet recently delighted guests at the Museum with a lively jazz concert, as part of the Society's Music Series. Andrew (on piano) was joined by Franklin Rankin (guitar), Nick Panoutsos (bass) and Lucas Ebeling (drums).
On March 10, the Music Series presents The Irish Mist to celebrate St. Patrick's Day. See more information under Coming Events on this page.

The Garden City Village Board of Trustees has introduced its concept for St. Paul's School. Please visit the village website for up-to-date information.

CSSP and The Garden City Historical Society Presented Alternative to Demolition

The Committee to Save St. Paul's (CSSP) and The Garden City Historical Society presented an alternative proposal ("The Community First") to the demolition of St. Paul's School to the Village Board of Trustees on June 29, 2010. The plan called for preservation and rehabilitation the former boys school and restoration of 10,500 square feet on the main floor and chapel for public use. In an April 27, 2011 public referendum, Garden City residents voted overwhelmingly NOT to support bonds to demolish St. Paul's, 3,290 to 1120. In October 2012, consultants Erwin & Bielinski issued a report rejecting the proposal. In December 2012, the Village Board of Trustees effectively stalled all efforts by passing a motion, by a 5 to 3 vote, not to proceed with the Committee's and Historical Society's proposal. Please stay tuned.

Read news related to referendum:
Huffington Post blog
When We Keep It
View the News 12 Editorial "Fate of a Landmark"  
(April 15, 2011)

Charles Lindberg Returns to the  Historical Society Museum

Carter Granville sculpture, Charles Lindbergh, was moved from the Garden City Public Library back to its original owner, The Garden City Historical Society. The sculpture had been on long-term loan. Charles Lindbergh made the first solo non-stop flight across the Atlantic Ocean on May 20-21, 1927. He flew from Garden City to Paris in about 33 hours in a Ryan monoplane named the Spirit of St. Louis.
Pictured, left to right, are Village Historians Bill Bellmer and Suzie Alvey, with Society Trustee Bill Garry.

Preservation Report

Interested in knowing where historic sites are in Garden City? The Society's Archives Committee has prepared a flyer, "Garden City Homes (c. 1872-1875) listed in 1978 on the Prestigious National Register of Historic Places."  Authorized by the Historic Preservation Act of 1966, the National Park Service certifies National Register sites as being historically significant to their communities. The Village of Garden City has the largest cluster of National Register historic homes of any community on Long Island.


2019 Children's Juried Art Contest

The theme of The Garden City Historical Society's 2019 Children's Juried Art Contest and Exhibit is "Heroes of Garden City." The 14th annual event is currently on-going and children attending Garden City Schools can received information on entering the contest by asking their school's art teacher. This year's reception for winning artists will be held April 7 in the lovely setting of The Garden City Historical Society Museum. All artwork will be on display during the week following the reception. Event sponsor: Dick Blick Art Materials of Carle Place, Long Island. At right: The 2018 Children's Juried Art Contest winners with Society Education chairperson Mary Jane Caldwell and contest judge, Greg Schnoor from Barnes Gallery. 

St. Paul's Preservation Effort

he Garden City Historical Society continues its effort to preserve St. Paul's School. A video, titled "Save St. Paul's Now: Protect Garden City's DNA," has been prepared by The Garden City Historical Society and The Committee to Save St. Paul's. To receive this free DVD, email Society at and provide your name and address.

The Society for the Preservation of Long Island Antiquities (SPLIA), Long Island's regional preservation organization, named St. Paul's School to its inaugural list of (2010) Endangered Historic Sites. Read the full list of 2010 Endangered Sites.

Coming Events at the Museum:

Spring 2019 Events

Saturday, June 1, 9AM-3PM
Annual A. T. Stewart Flea Market

Friday evening, September 20, Annual Benefit, Garden City Hotel
The Society's annual benefit supports our capital campaign to restore and preserve the exterior of the Museum. This year, the Society will pay special tribute to the 150th anniversary of the founding of Garden City by Alexander T. Stewart, and the 100th anniversary of the incorporation of the Village of Garden City.


The Garden City Historical Society welcomes you to its official website, and encourages all our visitors to log on frequently to learn about the latest renovations to the Society’s headquarters, the Garden City Historical Society Museum, its 1872 Stewart-era home on Eleventh Street (Garden City, Long Island, New York), or to share your thoughts about the preservation of Village treasures.

Since its beginning in 1975, the Society has been privileged to be the recipient of many volunteer hours given selflessly by devoted individuals who live in the Village of Garden City or who have ties to our lovely community. It is through these volunteer efforts that we present our website to you. Please feel free to browse our pages, find out about our Events and Lectures or review a current report by our House Committee on renovations to our Garden City Historical Society Museum and Exhibit Hall.

While visiting, stop at our Store to purchase a small remembrance of our historic village for a family member or friend, or purchase a commemorative brick to mark an anniversary, a birthday or a milestone – perhaps your move to Garden City or your company’s many years as a corporate community member.

On this site, you can also find information about Membership, which includes a complimentary copy of our Newsletter, Historical Notes.

About Us presents a short history of our organization. We are developing our Artifacts and Donations page, where you will soon be able to review the latest additions to our period collections, as well as a listing of our library collection, which can be viewed, upon request to the Society.  

Please feel free to contact us with your comments, requests or suggestions at A Society representative will reply to your comment or inquiry.

Thank your for your interest.

The Garden City Historical Society Museum
109 Eleventh Street, Garden City, New York 11530

Hosted by Connetrix